This was my second order from Succulents Direct and previously I was super thrilled with the quality of the plants (5++stars). However, the Icebergs were a bit of a disappointment. Quite a few of them had black spot - there were only a few that were black spot free. You did send me two extra plants, which I appreciate and understood was meant to "make up for the less than perfect plants you sent me" but I wasn't thrilled at all. The remainder of the order, consisting of succulents, was perfect.